Stage 1: Grammar – Understanding What Verbal Reasoning Is
- Focus: Teach the building blocks of verbal reasoning—words, relationships, and basic logical structures.
- Example: Identifying synonyms, antonyms, and analogies.
- Students learn what verbal reasoning entails: the ability to understand and evaluate relationships between concepts expressed in words.
- They practice identifying relationships in analogies:
- Example: "Cat is to kitten as dog is to ____ (puppy)."
- They explore basic logical statements: "If all A are B, and C is A, then C is B."
- Outcome: Students grasp the "syntax" of verbal reasoning—the rules and structures that govern word relationships and logical connections.
Stage 2: Logic – Understanding How Verbal Reasoning Relates to Argumentation and Proofs
- Focus: Develop the ability to reason logically and infer conclusions from premises.
- Example: Drawing inferences from a passage.
- Students analyze verbal "proofs," determining whether conclusions follow logically from given premises.
- Example:
- Premise: "All mammals are warm-blooded."
- Premise: "Whales are mammals."
- Conclusion: "Therefore, whales are warm-blooded."
- They learn to identify faulty reasoning:
- "If whales are mammals, and dolphins are mammals, then all mammals are whales." (False conclusion based on a misunderstanding of relationships.)
- Outcome: Students connect verbal reasoning to the principles of inference, deduction, and pattern recognition, enabling them to analyze arguments critically.
Stage 3: Rhetoric – Using Verbal Reasoning to Express and Argue Effectively
- Focus: Teach students to articulate ideas clearly, build convincing arguments, and critique others’ reasoning.
- Example: Writing or debating a response to a prompt.
- Students use verbal proofs to support a thesis:
- Example: Prompt: "Is honesty always the best policy?"
- Argument: "Honesty fosters trust, which is the foundation of relationships. Without trust, collaboration and progress are hindered. For instance, when scientists share data honestly, discoveries flourish. Therefore, honesty, while not always convenient, is ultimately the best policy."
- They also practice critiquing weak arguments, identifying logical fallacies, and proposing counterexamples.
- Outcome: Students master the ability to express their thoughts, defend their ideas, and evaluate others' reasoning, empowering them to thrive in academic, social, and professional contexts.